Is Education Over-rated?

“Our performance efficiency is 99.9999% – six sigma ranking. We have 5,000 members working in coordination.  Out of 400,000 transactions every day, the error factor is 1 in every 20,000,000” said the President of a service organisation.

This is the organization which collects lunch boxes (dabbas) in the morning from the homes spread over 60 by 30 km city called Mumbai. These lunch packs are then delivered to their owners working in various nooks and corners of Mumbai. Post lunch, they collect the empty boxes and get them back to the respective houses by the same evening

.Bombay DabbawalaBombay Dabbawalas

This organisation is not a giant corporate like IBM, Wal-mart or Coca cola.  Almost all its members are illiterate and school drop-outs. It has functioned for over 125 years and gets only more efficient by the day.

The process is extremely complicated and needs perfect coordination. They don’t use technology nor do they use fuel-driven vehicles.  They work on foot or use cycles and suburban trains to transfer the boxes over 65-70kms every day, making it a 100% eco-friendly system.  It is a perfect example of the most complicated job done in the simplest way.

To provide better coordination and thus efficiency, the delivery people are divided in different groups. In the process, the dabbas change hands 6 times. But they have a system to ensure there is no mix-up in the process. Their lack of education has not held them back in following the best lessons taught in the world’s top ranked management schools like Harvard, Oxford and so on.  On the contrary, this set-up is taken up as a case study by the said schools.

They believe in fixed prices.  No favours or bias in price.

There’s no gossip at work.  Even when Prince Charles wanted to talk to the members, they refused to have a discussion with him while they were on duty.  Their working impressed him so much, that Prince Charles  invited two of them to his marriage in 2005 at par with Queen of Gwalior.

Each member carries aprx 40 dabbas (boxes), weighing 60 to 65kgs on their head most of the day.   For each building, one delivery person is assigned the responsibility of collecting the boxes.   These boxes are then assembled at the local suburban train station, and are reallocated to groups based on the destination train station.

At the destination stations, the boxes again are regrouped to specific building (And floor of building in some cases).  Freshly cooked meals are thus delivered from home to the customer within 3 hours commute over foot, cycles and train.

As one can imagine they had to develop a system to identify which box needs to be go where. They introduced the most practical coding system which is marked on each box.  It identifies who would collect each box from which building in which suburb.  The code also includes who would deliver information – right down to the floor of a particular building.   This coding system can be understood by the most uneducated person and at the same time leaves an almost zero margin for error!

They have also created a cost free advertisement system for themselves.  Every member has to wear the white cap which by itself has become a logo.  This identification has proven to be a boon as they are blocked by no authority/security. Everyone respects their need for punctuality to ensure the boxes reach the office employees well in time for lunch.

All members have to strictly follow the rules and any deviation attracts a penalty.   For example, if a delivery person is found on duty without a cap or any customer makes a complaint against them they are penalized the same day.   Penalty has to be paid the same day to be able to continue with the delivery, the next day.

They do not have any employer-employee relationship.  Each member is a shareholder and hence a stake holder in the operation.  They have had no labour strike during 125 years of the association’s existence.  The punctuality, complaint record and output all count towards their share of pooled funds and reward. They are all part of an association which collects a small fee every month, which in turn is fully donated for a social cause.

Minimum overheads and optimum output is the lesson I learn from these hard-working dabbawalas.

This example proves that literacy and technology is not essential to achieve perfection.  It is whole-hearted devotion and the right attitude which matters most.

Written : Badri Baldawa

Edited  : Meeta Kabra

This entry was posted in Business, Challenge, Education and tagged , , by badri. Bookmark the permalink.

About badri

As I approached 68 (2013), my son, Anand insisted that I had proven enough in my 45-year long career and it was time I took life a little easier; enjoy traveling (that I love) and social life. Yet, I somehow wanted to contribute positively and was exploring my options. My son-in-law, Navin suggested that I should write and share my experiences, “being a self-made man, you should tell the next generation how you overcame various obstacles to reach this position, in both, business and social circles.” He pointed out that while I was sharing my experiences with family and friends, as they approached me, a blog had the potential to take your voice to many, many more. He also insisted that I start mentoring youngsters who were new in their businesses. I was convinced. I offered my services pro bono, as part of a Guidance Program. Also, I started writing on this blog, bringing out figments from my memory as experiences that might be of value to the readers here. My daughter Meeta is sweet enough to spare her time to edit what I write. As a youngster, I thought one meal a day, one set of school uniform a year, a public place to study, lack of finance and basic shelter would keep me from achieving my dreams. To compensate, I started giving 110% of what was normally expected. Yes, 110% even in bad deeds! This worked. The very limitations started inspiring me in different phases of my life – meritorious results in studies; strength to shoulder family responsibilities; satisfied employers; establishing a successful business of my own; and in my adventure trips and other travel plans. Having done what I wanted to, I agreed it was time for me to expose myself! I felt, through this blog, I could and should share my expereinces. Hopefully, readers would find some bits useful and if not, they’d enjoy reading. Look forward to interact with you. Happy Reading, Badri Baldawa

4 thoughts on “Is Education Over-rated?

  1. I have never been to Mumbai but I have read about this lunchbox chain in Mumbai at a lot of places. There’s also a bollywood movie on this which was up for the nominations to the oscars. The movie is ‘Lunchbox’ which is really great movie and one should watch it to see how this dabba walas work in Mumbai to deliver the right dabba to right place at right time. Its truly inspiring to see that how housewives and husbands going to their jobs rely on this system which is handled completely by the people who aren’t even 10th passed.

  2. One more practice regarding dabba is prevalent in Mumbai. Use me in which remaining food is povided to needy hungry people in slum area in Mumbai withing 1 hour. Its too intersesting.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *